Continuous testing vs test automation
Automation Management Agile
17 mins read
November 10, 2024

Continuous testing vs test automation: What is the difference?

With QA moving at breakneck speed, itā€™s tempting to think that faster is always the goal. But in software testing, speed isn't everything. If youā€™re rolling out updates non-stop without knowing if they workā€”or worse, if they break something else,ā€”you take too many risks. To avoid them, you need continuous testingā€¦ Or is it test automation? Or both of them? These two approaches often sound similar, but you should solve different problems with them. Curious about what sets them apart and why it matters? This guide is going to be your flashlight in the dark.

photo
photo
Robert Weingartz
Nurlan Suleymanov

What is continuous testing?

Continuous testing is the practice of running tests automatically at every stage of the development process to catch issues early and provide instant feedback.

Now, using the word ā€œautomaticallyā€ should not confuse you or lead you to any conclusions.

Think of it like this: in QA, waiting until the end of a project to test means risking big issues you could have fixed earlier. With continuous testing, every update to the code triggers tests immediately. If thereā€™s a bug or a failure, you know immediatelyā€”no surprises. Itā€™s having a quality check running alongside every step, so you can tackle issues as soon as they appear and keep the project on track.

Itā€™s tightly integrated with Continuous Integration (CI) and Continuous Delivery (CD). CI involves automatically integrating code changes into a shared repository, while CD takes it a step further by automating the release process to production.

Benefits of continuous testing

So how does continuous testing help you stay ahead and keep quality high? Hereā€™s what it brings to your workflow:

  • Catch issues early. You get immediate feedback, so youā€™re not blindsided by bugs later on.
  • Boost your teamā€™s confidence. Knowing that tests run with each change means fewer last-minute surprises.
  • Speed up delivery. Faster fixes mean faster releases. You keep the pace without sacrificing quality.
  • Improve collaboration. Continuous feedback helps the developers and QA teams stay aligned, reducing rework.
  • Lower overall costs. Fixing issues early prevents costly fixes down the road.

With continuous testing, youā€™re always one step ahead, delivering better software at every stage.

Challenges of continuous testing

No matter how beneficial, continuous testing doesnā€™t guarantee perfectionā€”it comes with challenges. But donā€™t worry, knowing them helps you stay prepared and tackle them head-on. Letā€™s look at the most common challenges:

  • Complex setup: Getting continuous testing started can be time-consuming. Invest time upfront to automate your tests and integrate them smoothly into your pipeline.
  • Test maintenance: Tests break or become outdated as the code evolves. Keep your test suite up-to-date and regularly review your tests to ensure they stay relevant.
  • False positives: Running continuous automated tests can flag issues that arenā€™t really there. So completely relying on them would be a mistake. Regularly refine your test scripts and use proper test data to reduce noise.
  • Resource heavy: Carrying out tests constantly can also consume server resources. Scale your infrastructure or optimise test execution to keep everything running smoothly.
  • Skill gaps: Your team might need new skills for automation. Provide training to help everyone get up to speed with the tools and processes.

Continuous testing isnā€™t without its bumps, but with the right approach, you can turn these challenges into opportunities for better, faster releases.

Best continuous testing tools

Want to rock continuous testing? It is most effective when paired with the right tools that integrate seamlessly into your development pipeline. Test Management Systems (TMS) are great examples of that. They play a pivotal role in continuous testing by helping you organise, automate, and track the test execution across the entire development cycle. With a robust TMS, you can:Ā 

  • Run the tests automatically,Ā 
  • Deliver the feedback instantly
  • Keep the testing process efficient and scalableĀ 

With that in mind, letā€™s give you the prime examples of continuous testing tools:

  • aqua cloud is a top-tier TMS that will enhance your continuous testing. AI-powered test case generation means no aspect of the software is left untested, as it allows you to automatically create test cases from requirements in seconds. With 100% traceability, you can instantly link tests to requirements, providing full visibility and making it easier to track progress. aqua’s centralised repository is your CI efforts ally as it collects manual and automated test data in one place, keeping all tests organised and accessible in real-time for collaboration. The AI Copilot offers intelligent insights that streamline test execution by automatically identifying gaps in your testing coverage. aquaā€™s Capture integration lets you instantly capture and report bugs with just a click, seamlessly feeding into your CI/CD pipeline. Moreover, aqua integrates effortlessly with major CI/CD tools like Jenkins, Selenium, Azure DevOps, and Jira, allowing for automated testing with each code change. Ready to rock your continuous testing efforts?

Give your continuous testing efforts a 100% AI-powered boost with a few clicks

Try aqua for free
  • Selenium
    Selenium is a popular choice for automating web applications. It gives you full control over your test scripts and supports multiple programming languages. However, the setup is a bit complex, and scaling tests can be tricky. You can easily enhance your efforts with aqua cloud integration. Itā€™s going to make your Selenium setup more efficient.
  • TestComplete
    TestComplete offers a user-friendly interface and supports automated testing for both desktop and mobile applications. It’s quick to get started with, but performance can slow down as your test suite expands. Its pricing is another concern for smaller teams or startups.
  • Jenkins
    Jenkins is widely used for continuous integration and running automated tests in your CI pipeline. Itā€™s highly customisable, with an extensive range of plugins. However, it can take time to set up, and fine-tuning the system to match your needs can be a challenge. Integrating aqua cloud with Jenkins will help you get the best out of your testing workflow.

Now you have a clearer picture of continuous testing and the tools to make it work. Itā€™s time to dig deeper into one of the key components of itā€”automated testing.

What is test automation?

Test automation is the practice of using tools and scripts to automatically run tests of your system. With automation, you can check whether your system works as expected without running each test manually. Instead of relying on human testers to go through every test case, automation allows you to run hundreds or even thousands of tests quickly and repeatedly.Ā 

Although test automation does not directly mean continuous testing, it is a key part of it. With automated tests running at every stage of development, you can get instant feedback and catch bugs earlier. It allows for faster releases while keeping your software quality intactā€”especially when combined with CI/CD.Ā 

Benefits of test automation

So how does test automation help you improve your testing process? Hereā€™s what it brings to the table:

  • Increased speed. Tests run much faster than manual testing. It gives you more time for development and improves your release cycle.
  • Better defect detection. Different studies show different numbers, but thereā€™s a consensus that automation gives you much better results in defect detection speed, up to 90%.
  • Consistency. Automated tests perform the same way every time. It eliminates human error and stays unaffected in different situations, unlike humans.
  • Greater test coverage. You can test more scenarios, more often, covering a wider range of cases than manual testers could realistically handle.
  • Faster feedback. Immediate results mean you can fix bugs right away. One study shows that with automation, developersā€™ feedback response times are down by 80%.
  • Reusability. Once written, you can reuse automated tests for future releases and save time and effort in the long run.

With automation, testing becomes more efficient, accurate, and scalable, which is a huge win for QA and dev teams and the final product.

Challenges of test automation

Test automation also has its challenges. Hereā€™s what you might face when applying automation:

  • Tool selection: As you rely on tools choosing the right automation tool can be tough, especially when there are so many options. Picking the wrong tool will limit your ability to scale or integrate with other systems.
  • Complex test cases: Not all tests are easy to automate. Some test cases require complex setups or user interactions that are difficult to capture in scripts.
  • Flaky tests. Automated tests can sometimes fail randomly due to environmental factors, timing issues, or race conditions. Identifying and fixing these flaky tests takes extra time.
  • High initial cost. Building a comprehensive automation suite can be costly, not just in terms of tool purchase, but also the resources needed to write and manage the scripts.

Test automation is powerful, but it takes careful planning and ongoing effort to make it work for you. With the right setup, you can overcome these challenges and unlock faster, more reliable testing.

Best Test Automation Tools

As you see, test automation accelerates testing and ensures reliability at scale, but choosing the right tools is essential. A powerful TMS can optimise automation by helping you organise and manage your test scripts, ensuring smooth execution throughout development. Letā€™s look at the best test automation tools together:

  • aqua cloud: While aqua cloud isnā€™t an automation tool itself, it enhances your automation efforts by integrating with tools like Selenium, Jenkins, and others. aquaā€™s CI/CD integrations ensure tests run automatically with code changes, delivering immediate feedback and speeding up release cycles. aqua also helps you automate key testing processes, such as generating requirements, test cases, and test data in seconds, saving you valuable time. It provides 100% traceability, linking automated tests to requirements, and ensuring full coverage. With a centralised repository, aqua organises all your test data, making it easier to manage. The AI Copilot offers insights for test optimisation, and Capture integration enables fast bug reporting directly from tests. aqua cloud might not be an automation solution, but it gives the exact amount of automation you need in your testing.

Automate 200% of your testing efforts with a few clicks

Try aqua cloud for free
  • Robot Framework
    An open-source tool, Robot Framework offers a keyword-driven approach. It makes tests highly readable and accessible for non-developers. Itā€™s versatile, working well with various test libraries, but is best suited for teams familiar with Python.
  • Ranorex
    Known for its support across desktop, web, and mobile platforms, Ranorex is helpful for both non-coders and automation experts. And if youā€™re using aqua cloud, you can boost your testing efforts even more with seamless Ranorex integration, adding centralised control and streamlined reporting to your automated tests.
  • Tosca by Tricentis
    Tosca uses model-based test automation. It simplifies complex test automation without needing heavy scripting. However, it is a solution designed for enterprise environments and lacks flexibility in a lot of aspects.

Now you know almost everything you need regarding both concepts. Itā€™s time to point out the key differences.

Best automation tips?
1. Your tests should be parallel-friendly, otherwise, you're gonna have a bad time scaling
2. Don't use sleeps
3. Have test metrics for your test-suite
4. Prevent flaky tests by stress testing any newly created test
5. Tackle flaky tests as soon as they come up, can't tell you how many flaky tests ended up being edge cases and rare/real bugs
6. Don't be afraid to add data attributes to the codebase to make tests more robust
7. Everybody on your team should know how to write an E2E test
8. Automation should be part of the dev culture

BaseCase Reddit

Differences between continuous testing and test automation

So, how do you differ between continuous testing and test automation? Letā€™s look at the differences in a neat and organised table format:

Aspect Continuous Testing Test Automation
Purpose and Scope Embeds testing at every development stage, providing immediate feedback on code quality continuously. Automates specific testing tasks to reduce manual effort and speed up repetitive effort.
Integration in Development Closely integrates with CI/CD pipelines, triggering tests automatically with each code update. Often used independently of CI/CD, running tests on demand without requiring a continuous setup.
Feedback Timing Offers real-time feedback with each code change, allowing quicker responses to issues. Provides faster results compared to manual testing but feedback may not be as immediate.
Tools and Management Uses a suite of tools for various test types (unit, performance, security), needing coordinated management. Relies on specific frameworks (e.g., Selenium, Cypress) to automate defined tests.
Relationship Continuous testing is a broad practice that includes and uses automated tests. Test automation is a technique that supports continuous testing by automating individual tests.

Itā€™s important to know that they are related and support each other. However, you can not use the terms interchangeably because of their scope, purposes, and relationships.

Conclusion

Both continuous testing and test automation are essential in building high-quality, reliable software faster. While continuous testing brings testing to every stage of development, test automation powers it by reducing manual effort. Together, they keep your pipeline efficient and responsive to change. So, as you scale your QA efforts, ask yourselfā€”are you using the right mix to ensure both speed and quality in your releases?

On this page:
See more
Speed up your releases x2 with aqua
Start for free
step
FAQ
What is the difference between automation testing and continuous testing?

Automation testing uses tools to run specific tests automatically, reducing manual effort. Continuous testing, however, integrates testing into every stage of development, providing constant feedback on code quality with each change.

Which tool is used for continuous testing?

Tools like Jenkins, CircleCI, and aqua cloud are commonly used for continuous testing, helping teams automate and integrate testing throughout the CI/CD pipeline.

closed icon